Connect with us

Formula E

Doubt Cast on Sims’ Monaco Penalty Judgement

New footage showing the incident between Sims, Bird and di Grassi emerges…

Image: Lucas di Grassi (Twitter)

Fresh footage of the incident between Alexander Sims, Sam Bird and Lucas di Grassi at the Monaco E-Prix has emerged, casting doubt on whether Sims deserved to be given a penalty.

The incident, which ended with Sims receiving a grid penalty for the upcoming Berlin E-Prix, was captured on di Grassi’s onboard camera and shows it was triggered by Bird lightly touching the back of Sims’ BMW.

This caused the British racer to lock his rear wheels and take avoiding action, which in turn appears to have caused him to move left and collect di Grassi.

The onboard footage, which was not shown during the official feed coverage of the race, is not believed to have been shown to the drivers at their hearing after the race.

“You can see from the onboard that Sam [Bird] taps the back of me, not maliciously, but my wheels come off the floor momentarily and I lock up,” Sims told e-racing365 on Tuesday.

“I can’t then slow down and I am heading for Antonio [Felix da Costa] who obviously I don’t want to hit so I move left and unfortunately Lucas is taken out of the race.

“I just don’t see how I can be accountable for that and it is especially obvious with this onboard footage.

Sims explained that processing the incident as it happened and then attending the stewards’ meeting after the race was difficult.

“The problem is that this all happens within half a second and then as soon as it has happened I am scrabbling around trying to get around the corner and recover the situation,” he said.

“You don’t immediately log in your mind what just happened. So I went to the stewards completely honestly and with what I thought might have happened at the time.

“Maybe this is my downfall and I am too honest but from the camera which is looking down the straight, which, by the way, is maybe 100 meters from the incident, it is difficult to make an accurate judgement call on that, isn’t it?

“So from the evidence we saw it was difficult for me to argue anything other than it was my fault for hitting Lucas.

“Then we see this onboard and it is quite clear that Sam just tapped me, and like I say it was in itself not a malicious thing.”

The International Sporting Code states that under Article 14.1.1 of its Appeals section:

“If, in Competitions forming part of an FIA Championship, cup, trophy, challenge or series, or of an international series, a significant and relevant new element is discovered which was unavailable to the parties seeking the review at the time of the Competition concerned, whether or not the stewards have already given a ruling, these stewards or, failing this, those designated by the FIA, must meet (in person or by other means) on a date agreed amongst themselves, summoning the party or parties concerned to hear any relevant explanations and to judge in the light of the facts and elements brought before them.”

Therefore, BMW i Andretti Motorsport could have some recourse for retrospective action regarding the incident should the onboard not have been viewed by stewards as part of their investigation to the incident.

Sam Smith is e-racing365's Formula E Editor. A 20-year veteran in motorsports media, including press officer roles in both the FIA Sportscar Championship and at Lola Group, Smith is a well-known face in the Formula E paddock, where he served as series editor for from 2014-17. Contact Sam

1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. Avatar


    May 14, 2019 at 2:11 pm

    The driver at fault here was Di Grassi – it was an insane overtaking move.

    Sam can be seen reacting to Di Grassi and stopping moving to the left and getting onto the racing line. Sims didn’t.

    I still think Di Grassi should be penalised and not Bird or Sims.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More in Formula E